⋙ Read My Secret Camera Life in the Lodz Ghetto Frank Dabba Smith Mendel Grossman 9781845078928 Books

My Secret Camera Life in the Lodz Ghetto Frank Dabba Smith Mendel Grossman 9781845078928 Books

Download As PDF : My Secret Camera Life in the Lodz Ghetto Frank Dabba Smith Mendel Grossman 9781845078928 Books

My Secret Camera Life in the Lodz Ghetto Frank Dabba Smith Mendel Grossman 9781845078928 Books

Mendel Grossman did humanity a great service in risking his life to bring the world visual proof of the horrific tragedies within the Lodz ghetto during the holocaust. Unfortunately the text of this book is written in such an over-simplified style that the publisher's targeted age range; 3rd thorough 5th graders are easily bored by it.
Aside from a few weak descriptions of these powerful images, I felt besieged by Frank Smith's one-sided listing of war facts. Smith's prose melodramatically recites the war's background from a narrow perspective that seems designed to inflame young readers about the suffering of only one race. With so many other races alongside the Jewish people targeted for Nazi genocide, I felt that a more sober and complete narrative about this tragic time in history would have provide the book with the necessary facts to place it among the best of it's genre.
My Secret Camera deprives its readers of a powerful chance to merge the photography of this Jewish ghetto and a first-hand historical account of this terrible time in history. After reading and owning so many incredible and moving Jewish and non-Jewish authored books about the holocaust, I can only recommend you purchase this book for it's pictures - it's not worth reading.


Tags : My Secret Camera: Life in the Lodz Ghetto [Frank Dabba Smith, Mendel Grossman] on Amazon.com. *FREE* shipping on qualifying offers. <div>Mendel Grossman was a prisoner in Poland's Lodz Ghetto for more than four years. His job was to take photographs for work permits,Frank Dabba Smith, Mendel Grossman,My Secret Camera: Life in the Lodz Ghetto,Lincoln Children's Books,1845078926,History - Holocaust,Holocaust, Jewish (1939-1945);Poland;¡âodâz;Personal narratives;Juvenile literature.,Holocaust, Jewish (1939-1945);Poland;¡âodâz;Pictorial works;Juvenile literature.,Jews;Persecutions;Poland;¡âodâz;Juvenile literature.,Children's BooksAges 9-12 Nonfiction,Children: Grades 1-2,Holocaust, Jewish (1939-1945),JUVENILE FICTION Historical Holocaust,Jews,Juvenile Nonfiction,Juvenile Nonfiction History Holocaust,Juvenile literature,Persecutions,Personal narratives,Pictorial works,Poland,World history: Second World War,íGodGz

My Secret Camera Life in the Lodz Ghetto Frank Dabba Smith Mendel Grossman 9781845078928 Books Reviews

The pictures are interesting but too few. The text is of appallingly bad taste - mawkish and over-interpreted. The author doesn't know how to write about tragedy, but kitsch he knows - so he daubs schmaltz galore.
This was real.
I was expecting more. I did not realize it was written as children's literature.
OK but not as in-depth as Visniac;s book.
This was a difficult read for my 10yo due to the subject matter not the writing. He says liked the book but it was too sad for him.
Great purchasing experience.
This is another important book on Mendel Grosman the photographer of Lodz the quality of printing in this book is better than the other book on him "Camera in the Ghetto" as some pictures are reprinted here, but still its very good, even if you havent heard about this great human being and hero!
Mendel Grossman did humanity a great service in risking his life to bring the world visual proof of the horrific tragedies within the Lodz ghetto during the holocaust. Unfortunately the text of this book is written in such an over-simplified style that the publisher's targeted age range; 3rd thorough 5th graders are easily bored by it.
Aside from a few weak descriptions of these powerful images, I felt besieged by Frank Smith's one-sided listing of war facts. Smith's prose melodramatically recites the war's background from a narrow perspective that seems designed to inflame young readers about the suffering of only one race. With so many other races alongside the Jewish people targeted for Nazi genocide, I felt that a more sober and complete narrative about this tragic time in history would have provide the book with the necessary facts to place it among the best of it's genre.
My Secret Camera deprives its readers of a powerful chance to merge the photography of this Jewish ghetto and a first-hand historical account of this terrible time in history. After reading and owning so many incredible and moving Jewish and non-Jewish authored books about the holocaust, I can only recommend you purchase this book for it's pictures - it's not worth reading.